critique

Hey! So, this thread was originally for my own idea in need of critiquing, but I no longer with to have my idea up here! Due to this, I've changed the thread to a place for people to ask for critiquing and to post their ideas. Have fun.

So I've been working on some music for one of my games and I would like an opinion on what you guys think. I primarily work with Chiptune and 8bit styles with hints of dubstep from time to time. Let me know what you guys think. Project A- Area1 Loopz Fruity Loopz Battle Loopz

I'm somewhat happy with how my first large city map turned out, but I could use some fresh eyes and opinions, particularly on a few things... This is Lower Drumwell, the less affluent of two regions in the overall city. I intentionally made most buildings small and compact as I was going for a...

I am making a better critique screenshot thread for those that want feedback on their maps, game art, etc. This one will be a bit different than the one we already have, there will be rules to follow so no one goes left unnoticed. The basics is simple, you have a screenshot and you want...

Hello everyone. Most forums have a thread like this, so I thought MV.co could use one too. Simple. Post your music and leave feedback for prior people who posted. Rules: Follow all forum rules. (Duh.) Leave detailed feedback for prior musicians/composers. Simply "I liked it" or "That...

I may have missed this and I apologize, but is there a post near the feedback/playtesting realm discussing how to be a good critic? I think a huge downfall for a number of communities is that they end up with a bad mix of new people who don't know how to honestly critique and experienced people...